How DTC Pages Drove +$337k/Month in Estimated Revenue for Hug Sleep with 22 Winning A/B Tests
22 winning experiments, 50 total A/B tests, and a 2-year CRO partnership - how data-driven optimization generated +$337k/month in estimated additional revenue for a Shark Tank sleep brand with a one-of-a-kind product.
50
A/B Tests Run
22
Winning Tests
2 Years
CRO Partnership
The Story Begins
Hug Sleep is the creator of the Sleep Pod - a revolutionary cocoon-style swaddle blanket that uses gentle compression to help adults and kids sleep better. Featured on Shark Tank, they carved out a unique niche as the lightweight, breathable alternative to weighted blankets. With a product category that is genuinely novel, Hug Sleep faced a distinctive challenge: convincing customers to try something they had never experienced before. Their Shark Tank appearance gave them massive brand awareness, but translating that awareness into conversions required a different kind of expertise.
The Challenge
When Hug Sleep partnered with DTC Pages in early 2023, they had strong brand recognition from Shark Tank and loyal customers who loved the product. But their store conversion rates were not matching their brand potential. Customers were highly price-sensitive - early tests proved adding even small costs like shipping insurance hurt conversion. The unique product category meant shoppers needed more education and trust signals before purchasing. Their Shark Tank social proof was not being leveraged strategically across the site. And product discovery was fragmented - customers could not easily find the right Sleep Pod variant for their needs.
Experiment Spotlights
We ran 50 A/B tests for Hug Sleep - 22 were winners. Here are 5 of the most impactful, with real data from Intelligems.
Placing the Shark Tank Video Front and Center on the Homepage
Hypothesis
Replacing the press banner with the actual Shark Tank video below the homepage banner will amplify social proof for new visitors and drive confirmation of brand credibility.
Before
After
The single biggest win of the entire engagement. All primary metrics showed confidence levels above 98% - making this one of the most statistically airtight experiments DTC Pages has ever run. The Shark Tank video did not just build trust - it drove action. New visitors who watched the video converted at dramatically higher rates. For a product category that requires trust before trial, leveraging an existing credibility asset in the right placement was transformative.
Making Quantity Breaks Impossible to Miss Across the Entire Site
Hypothesis
If we promote the quantity break offer at multiple touchpoints - announcement bar for all visitors, plus banners on collection pages - more people will become aware of the savings and take advantage of it.
Before
After
The quantity breaks offer already existed on product pages, but most visitors never saw it. By adding announcement bars and collection banners, we turned a hidden offer into a site-wide conversion driver. This test proved that visibility - not the offer itself - was the bottleneck. AOV actually increased by 3.65% as more customers opted into multi-packs.
Adding 'Pairs Best With' Product Recommendations on Every Product Page
Hypothesis
A curated product upsell module showing complementary items will reduce friction in discovery and increase both AOV and revenue per visitor.
Before
After
Unlike many upsell modules that boost AOV at the expense of conversion, this one improved ALL metrics. The curated pairings felt helpful rather than pushy - customers genuinely valued the complementary product suggestions. CVR, RPV, PPV, and AOV all moved in the right direction, a rare clean sweep that validated the module design.
Lowering Sleep Pod Prices and Watching Revenue Climb
Hypothesis
Reducing prices on the Sleep Pod Move ($69.99) and Hooded Move ($79.99) will lower the barrier to purchase, increasing conversion volume enough to offset the per-unit revenue decrease.
Before
After
This confirmed a pattern we saw throughout the Hug Sleep engagement: the customer base is price-elastic. The lower prices did not just increase conversions - they expanded the total addressable market. With the price gap between products narrowed, the strategy shifted to increasing AOV through quantity breaks, bundles, and shipping optimization - which became some of the biggest subsequent wins.
Eliminating the Last Objection with Hassle-Free Returns in the Cart
Hypothesis
Adding a hassle-free returns guarantee banner in the cart will tackle the final purchase objection for a product category that is completely unique and untried by most customers.
Before
After
Hug Sleep products are unlike anything else on the market. Trying a completely novel product carries inherent risk - what if you do not like it? The hassle-free returns guarantee placed at the last decision point (the cart) eliminated that final objection. The +11.13% CVR lift at 95.5% confidence proved that reducing perceived risk at checkout is just as important as building desire on the product page.
The Engagement
2 years
Duration
50+
Experiments
22
Winners
Over a 2-year partnership from April 2023 to April 2025, DTC Pages ran 50 A/B tests for Hug Sleep across pricing, shipping, homepage, product pages, collections, cart, and sitewide elements. 22 tests produced statistically significant wins, generating a combined +$337k/month in estimated additional revenue (per Intelligems and Convert analytics). The engagement spanned two distinct phases - an initial discovery phase focused on landing pages, hero copy, product images, and early price testing, followed by a deep optimization phase that doubled down on quantity breaks, social proof amplification, and systematic shipping and pricing optimization. The spotlight 5 experiments above represent the largest individual wins, but the true power was in the compounding effect of 22 validated improvements layered across the entire purchase funnel.
The Results
+$337k/mo
Est. Additional Revenue
22
Winning Experiments
+35.98%
Largest CVR Lift
Services Used
Want results like Hug Sleep?
Book a free CRO audit and discover how much revenue your Shopify store is leaving on the table.
Book a Free CRO Audit
